The sceptical CFO
With Paulo Almeida, CFO. About 5 minutes, spoken.
The brief
You run supply chain and planning at Northgate Components, an automotive components maker with five plants and about $110 million of revenue. You are asking Paulo Almeida, the CFO, for $250,000 for a demand-planning platform.
Your business case asks for $250,000 in year one and shows payback in about fifteen months. You wrote it, and the 14% carrying-cost rate in it is the one you chose. Today you pay about $70,000 a year for a workaround: expedite freight and contract planners. The vendor wants a decision this quarter. It has also quoted $70,000 for a first-year, two-plant start at Eastfield, which holds $2.2 million of the $5.8 million of inventory across the five plants.
Paulo has turned down two similar asks this year. The 2023 warehouse system ran over budget; you do not know the details. He answers to Folake Bello, the MD, and to the board.
Yours to decide
- The content of your case and any re-cut of it
- How the ask is staged: which plants first, in what order
- The gate metric, date and stop number you propose
- Your planning team's time, including cleaning master data
- The inventory number you put your name to
Not yours to decide
- Whether money is released (Paulo decides)
- Anything above Paulo's own release limit (the board decides)
- The carrying-cost rate finance uses
- The vendor's price for any scope other than the quotes you hold
| Line | $k |
|---|---|
| Implementation (vendor and integrator) | 150 |
| Licence, year one | 40 |
| Internal backfill for the planning team during rollout | 60 |
| Investment, year one | 250 |
| Licence from year two, each year | 40 |
| Workaround avoided: expedite freight | 45 |
| Workaround avoided: contract planners | 25 |
| Inventory carrying cost saved: $1.0m less inventory at 14% | 140 |
| Annual benefit | 210 |
| Payback | about 15 months |
| Today | After the platform (case) | |
|---|---|---|
| Inventory across five plants | $5.8m | $4.8m |
| Forecast accuracy (SKU, monthly) | 61% | 75% |
| SKUs | 6,200 | 6,200 |
| SKUs whose lead time was last reviewed before 2022 | 31% | not in the case |
| Inventory at the two Eastfield plants | $2.2m | — |
About 5 minutes. Talk as you would in the room. You can pause to think; say “let me think” and the counterpart will wait.
Paulo Almeida
CFO
05:00
Sign in to start.
Sign in with LinkedIn or Google. We use your name and email only to keep your attempts together and to limit free use. We never post to LinkedIn or send anything from your Google account.